Is Madelia Fire Department Relief Association or Minnesota Security Consortium a better-rated charity?

CharityIndex grades Madelia Fire Department Relief Association C+ and Minnesota Security Consortium C. Both figures come from public IRS filings; the best choice depends on the cause and outcomes you care about.

Madelia Fire Department Relief Association vs Minnesota Security Consortium

Q: How do Madelia Fire Department Relief Association and Minnesota Security Consortium compare?

Compare Madelia Fire Department Relief Association and Minnesota Security Consortium side by side on financial grade, revenue, program efficiency and reserves — all from IRS Form 990 data on CharityIndex.

Comparing Madelia Fire Department Relief Association and Minnesota Security Consortium side by side on financial grade, revenue, program efficiency and reserves — all from public IRS Form 990 data. CharityIndex grades Madelia Fire Department Relief Association C+ and Minnesota Security Consortium C.

Side by side

Madelia Fire Department Relief Association

C+★★★★

Minnesota Security Consortium

C★★★★

C+

Financial grade

$145K

Annual revenue

$140K

$131K

Total expenses

$136K

—

Program spendingshare of expenses

—

Cost to raise $100lower is better

—

$641K

Net assets

$5,505

Public Safety